Oh! Blog.

Oh! It's a blog. When life gives you lemons... throw them at someone you don't like.

Wednesday, February 07, 2007

Hyper-sensitivity a go-go

The grammar for today's 2nd grade lesson was "[blank] is as [blank] as." I had made an activity in which students measured each other's height and then wrote comparisons, as in "I am as tall as Chihiro," "Takahiro is taller than Ikuo" or whatever. My team-teaching partner approved this activity. I printed the worksheets.
Later, my colleague approached me to ask if we could change the activity a little. She was worried that my activity would upset the short kids. Would it be okay to change it to older/younger, rather than taller/shorter?
Well, sure, we can change it, if you don't mind wasting 50 sheets of paper for the sake of a minor change in the name of some imagined hypersensitivity. Goodness. Perhaps if my topic was actually controversial, like "I am as fanatical as" or "I am as much of an orphan as" but height? Goodness.
Perhaps I'm overanalysing the situation but... in case a student does have an issue about his height, should we (as teachers) not teach that physical qualities don't matter? Who cares if you're short? The message should be "no-one cares if you are shorter than everyone else," rather than "let's avoid discussing anything height-related when Kazuki's around."
Anyway. I was pissed at wasting so much paper, is all.

4 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Oh, that's all very easy for you to say, Mr 5'8''!

10:36 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

You're only on the comparitive now?!? Are you working from Total English? If so, hurrah, someone whose students are slower than mine. I had the "taller wa chotto..." discussion last week and we moved on to older/younger too. But without the waste of half a tree. Though that may be because I am lazier than you.

11:31 pm  
Blogger Suzette said...

I mis-spelled a Japanese poem in the Suzette Gazette and my supervisor asked if I wanted to reprint them all. 300 sheets of double-sided A5s because I wrote ใš instead ofใ€€ใ‚‹?! No thank you, just tell the kids to change it themselves! At least you can reuse the other side for scrap...

3:56 pm  
Blogger Raychaa said...

It'd be so hard to be a midget here, knowing that if you went to another country, you'd get stepped on by accident. (Oh, I'm heightist, by the way.) At least you weren't coerced into "how tall, how long". Remember that story? Involving a ruler and the homeroom-teacher crotch attack? Worst idea ever.

10:41 pm  

Post a Comment

<< Home